- Jason Lee
- Butch Brunner
- Anjul Nigam
- Bhaaskar Bhatnagar
- Brighton Sharbino
- Amy Brunner
- Hilarie Burton Morgan
- Nancy Brunner
- Roni Akurati
- Smith Bhatnagar
- Poorna Jagannathan
- Nalini Bhatnagar
- Samrat Chakrabarti
- Older Smith Bhatnagar
- Shoba Narayan
- Asha Bhatnagar
- Jake Busey
- Officer Dick
- Tim Guinee
- Officer Bob
- Alison Wright
- Mrs. Reynolds
- Austin Harrod
- Billy MacNamara
- James Hyland
- Stan Swanson
- Jack Hyland
- Steve Swanson
- Paul Castro Jr.
- Patrick
- Deema Aitken
- Dude #1
- Jacqui Denski
- School Teacher
- Ben Sloane
- Dude #2
- Jeremiah Burch III
- Rock Star Trick-or-Treater
- Luke Trevisan
- Boxer Trick-or-Treater
- Asher Kaminsky
- Vampire Trick-or-Treater
- Edward Prostak
- Middle-Aged Vampire
- Laurie Dawn
- Smiling Woman
- Randall McNeal
- Christian Man / Drugstore Employee
- Mike Lisenco
- Mayor
- Dan Coplan
- Paramedic Clemmons
- David Aranovich
- Police Officer
- Jessica Minhas
- Older Asha Bhatnagar
- Jennifer Bagley
- Woman Walking Dog
- Greta
- Dachshund
- Sophie Elise Meissner
- Dancer
- Henny Russell
- Christian Woman
- Norman Aaronson
- KFC Patron
- Kendall Beaulieu
- Trick or Treater-mouse
- Trevor Brooks
- Student / Baseball Player (uncredited)
- Alice Callahan
- Older Amy Brunner
- Robert Carley
- Nosy Neighbor / businessman (uncredited)
- Kaitlyn Cross
- Trick-or-Treater / Student (uncredited)
- Brianna Denski
- Trick-or-Treater / Student (uncredited)
- Jacob Devik
- Townsfolk
- Logan John
- Trick-or-treater & baseball Player
- Logan Kline
- Trick-or-Treater Fireman
- Sydney Lockhart
- Marilyn Monroe
- Doug McCausland
- Teen Partier #3
- Maximilian Amadeus Meisner
- Baseball Player
- Chap Melford
- Butch's Neighbor
- Patrick Mulligan
- Trick-or-Treater Scarecrow
- Sean E. O'Connor
- Accident Witness
- Bryson Pitts
- Rockwell Son
- Michael Power
- Ambulance Driver
- Emily Ram
- Sarita
- David Rosenthal
- Trick or Treater
- Nancy Rubel
- Townswoman
- William Rubel
- Townsfolk
- Ben Simon
- Baseball Player / Trick-or Treater (uncredited)
- Crystal Joy Turner
- Trick-or-treater & Travelor
- Evelyn Twarowski
- Trick-or-Treater
- Olivia Twarowski
- Trick-or-Treater
- Gabrielle Vuillaume
- Trick-or-Treater #6
