- Bing Crosby
- Father Chuck O'Malley
- Barry Fitzgerald
- Father Fitzgibbon
- Frank McHugh
- Father Timothy O'Dowd
- James Brown
- Ted Haines Jr.
- Gene Lockhart
- Ted Haines Sr.
- Jean Heather
- Carol James
- Porter Hall
- Mr. Belknap
- Fortunio Bonanova
- Tomaso Bozanni
- Eily Malyon
- Mrs. Carmody
- The Robert Mitchell Boy Choir
- Choir
- Risë Stevens
- Genevieve Linden
- Arnet Amos
- Singer
- Stanley Clements
- Tony Scaponi
- Adeline De Walt Reynolds
- Mrs. Molly Fitzgibbon
- Tom Dillon
- Police Officer Pat McCarthy
- Bobby Dolan Jr.
- Joseph
- Jimmie Dundee
- Fireman
- Virginia Farmer
- Parishioner
- Franklyn Farnum
- Church Usher
- William Frawley
- Max Dolan - the Publisher
- Don Gallaher
- Minor Role
- Martin Garralaga
- Zuñiga
- Julie Gibson
- Cab Driver
- Gibson Gowland
- Parishioner
- William Henry
- Doctor
- Connie Leon
- Mrs. Quimp's Neighbor
- Sybil Lewis
- Effie - Genevieve's Maid
- Hugh Maguire
- Pitch Pipe
- Joe Mangum
- Minor Role
- William Marion
- Parishioner
- George McKay
- Mr.Van Heusen
- Freddie Mercer
- Boys Choir Member
- Georgie Nokes
- Pee Wee
- Jack Norton
- Mr. Lilly
- Constance Purdy
- Mrs. Quimp's Neighbor at Window
- Jean Ransome
- Parishioner
- Paul Russell
- Parishioner
- Anita Sharp-Bolster
- Mrs. Hattie Quimp
- John Smith
- Choir Member
- William Smith
- Choir Member
- Count Stefenelli
- Parishioner
- Carl 'Alfalfa' Switzer
- Herman Langerhanke
- Robert Tafur
- Don Jose in 'Carmen'
- Cecil Weston
- Minor Role
