- Alicia Silverstone
- Kate
- Sharon Stone
- Aphrodite
- Christopher Walken
- Zeus
- Robin Weigert
- Vicky the Tree
- Ebon Moss-Bachrach
- Neil
- John Turturro
- Hades
- Kathleen Turner
- Styx
- Jeff Hiller
- First Follower
- Edie Falco
- Artemis
- Oliver Platt
- Apollo
- Rosie Perez
- Persephone
- Aasif Mandvi
- Maxwell
- Phylicia Rashad
- Demeter
- Nelsan Ellis
- Dionysus
- Glenn Fleshler
- Landauer
- Ajay Naidu
- The Producer
- Henry Zebrowski
- Hermes
- Steve Witting
- Carl
- Gideon Glick
- Eros
- Will Swenson
- Aries
- Cotter Smith
- Mayor of New York
- Tracee Chimo Pallero
- River Styx / Architect #1 (as Tracee Chimo)
- Eric Anderson
- Mayor Questioner #3
- Mark Kenneth Smaltz
- Mayor Questioner #1
- Stewart J. Zully
- Angry Man in Crowd
- Andre Ozim
- Wedding Guest
- Lauren Cohn
- Sheila
- Diezel Ramos
- Police officer
- Nick Blaemire
- Dana
- Alex Kruz
- Minor god
- Raymond McAnally
- Heckler #2
- Darlene Violette
- Heckler #1
- Arthur French
- End of Days Street Preacher
- Jian Leonardo
- Neil's Friend
- Sharon Wheatley
- Sylvie
- Jenilyn Rodriguez
- Wedding Guest
- Anna Rapp
- Panic New Yorker
- Evan Elise Owens
- Kate Look-A-Like
- Daniel Dugan
- Heckler #3
- Greg Paul
- Studio Cameraman
- Teena Byrd
- High Society Wedding Guest
- Patrick Husted
- Security Guard
- Laryssa Lauret
- Trudy
- Joseph Whelski
- Edwardian Chess Player
- Cruz Rodriguez
- Blanket huddler
- Jeremy Frutkin
- Wedding Guest
- Kevin Bielinski
- Spectator
- Uziman
- Wedding Guest
- Marcia M Francis
- Town Hall Crowd Heckler
- Sucen Amirak Nallem
- Human
- Carol Commissiong
- NYPD Uniform Officer
- Linda Mendivel
- Spectator
- John Mitchell
- Unruly Pedestrian
- Gil O'Brien
- Passerby
- Chris Vaina
- Blanket Crowd
- Richard R. Corapi
- Blanket Huddler
- Ilana Rapp
- Panic New Yorker
- Ryan Dodson
- Looter
- Randall McNeal
- Usher
- Brenna Gwyn Snowe
- Caroline
- Michael DeeJay Millz Mason
- Angry Man in Crowd
- Sarah Babb
- TV Newswoman
- Josh Mendelow
- Mayor Questioner #2
- Nimol Chhom
- Wedding Singer
- Marie Phillips
- Dead Edwardian in the Underworld
- George Belbusti
- Man Dodging Lightning
- Natalia Roldan
- Town Hall Spectator
- Jacobi Rain
- Blanket Crowd
- Solima Arnold
- Town Hall Spectator
- Agueda Ramirez
- High Society Wedding Guest
- Steven Vigil
- Crowd Heckler
- Frank Wolf Connell
- Blanket Crowd
- John Mavungo
- Wedding Guest
- Jasmine Ali
- Little Girl
- Rennel Turner
- Police officer
- Melanie Marod
- Wedding Singer
- Elaine Apruzzese
- Scrabble Player
- Anthony Auriemma
- Supporting
- Akim Black
- Blanket Huddler
- Roger Brenner
- Winter Crowd Gatherer
- Ann Chow
- Wedding Guest
- Michael Crowe
- Wedding Guest
- Jordan Elizabeth Gelber
- Banquet Party Member
- Oliana Glazman
- Wedding dancer
- Rosemary Howard
- Distraught Woman
- Emily Karaniewsky
- Wedding Guest
- Beth Katehis
- Walking Dead
- Heather M. Kayal
- Crowd Spectator with Lantern
- Samantha Kelly
- Wedding Guest
- Diane Kimbrell
- Passerby
- Steven G. Lawrence
- Interested Guy
- Eric Lommel
- Wedding Guest
- Annika Merkel
- Scrabble Player
- Sarah Miller
- Madeline Perkins - Passerby
- Hope Anne Nathan
- Blanket Huddler
- Jesse Newman
- Boom Operator
- Roy Pollack
- Upscale Party Goer
- Barbara Vincent
- TV Newswoman
- James Wilson
- Wedding Guest
