- Kelli Berglund
- Sally
- Jake Busey
- Charlie Sullivan
- Olivia Larsen
- Zoe
- Royce Johnson
- Sheriff D
- Joah Carmody
- Reed
- Maria Olsen
- The Witch / Zoe's Mom
- Zebedee Row
- Billy Sullivan
- Shiloh Verrico
- Martha / The Ghost
- Nikki Blonsky
- Mrs. E
- Jason James Richter
- Deputy T
- Joseph D'Onofrio
- Deputy Simmons
- Faye Giordano
- Little Sally
- Kylie Kiss
- Little Zoe
- Grace Narducci
- Karen / Sidekick 1
- Jacqueline Vené
- Laura / Sidekick 2 (as Jacqi Vene)
- Shifra Zuckerman
- Donna / Sidekick 3
- Riley Victoria
- Jade / Junior Sidekick
- Mary Anisi
- Sister Brigit
- Karen Xerri
- Witch 1
- Danielle Legris
- Witch 2
- Vanessa Urzia
- Middle School Sally
- Eva Jette Putrello
- Middle School Zoey
- David Aranovich
- Woody Malone
- Cynthia San Luis
- Nurse Esther
- Luke Patrick Duffy
- Tommy Farcas
- KhalilJai
- Bike Kid #1
- Vegas Chiddick
- Bike Kid #2
- Will White
- Bike Kid #3
- Christopher Gebauer
- Kevin
- Nicholas Duffy
- Young Billy
- Jack Lanyo
- Young Reed
- Kamryn Comparetto
- Little Girl / Martha's Hand (as Kamryn 'Toaster' Comparetto)
- Mack Pines
- Middle School Sidekick
- Ella Jordan Ferrauiola
- Middle School Sidekick
- Chloe Weiner
- Middle School Sidekick
- Theodore Tirado
- Baby Lilly
- Elizabeth Z. Blazey
- Clerk
- Brandon Meza
- Shadow
- Morgan Danielle-Cronheim
- Baseball Hand
- Izzy Kushner
- School Personnel
- Stuart Brietkopf
- School Personnel
- Chris Gross
- School Personnel / Police Officer
- Judy San Roman
- School Personnel
- James Carmody
- Jacked Kid on Steps
- John-Henry Genualdo
- Spike / Student / Extra
- Annie Killean
- Bar Extra
- Mike Kaphan
- Bar Extra
- Carla Saber Sardonil
- Bar Extra
- Jenna Ghildalsen
- Additional Witch
- Tauny Ventura
- Additional Witch
- Breana O'Connor
- Additional Witch
- Alida Lang
- Witch
- Louis Heneghan
- Hospital Officer
- Harry Azano
- EMT
- Cara Sanz
- EMT
- Carlos Cruz-Reyes
- EMT
- Guilian Abrigo
- Police Officer
- Paul Wallace
- Police Officer
- Relroy Vega
- Stanley Bricker
- Kaleigh Comparetto
- Student / Extra
- Brendan Gleeson
- Student / Extra
- Brynn Korpi
- Student / Extra
- Liliana Costanza
- Student / Extra
- Sydney Savage
- Student / Extra
- Tara Feirstein
- Student / Extra
- Jordy Erenfryd
- Student / Extra
- Sarah Kushner
- Student / Extra
- Ben Kushner
- Student / Extra
- Jacob Breitkopf
- Student / Extra
- Sammi Davidson
- Student / Extra
- Julia Mohl
- Student / Extra
- Cassidy McKenna
- Student / Extra
- Kendall Katsch
- Student / Extra
- Brice Cohen
- Student / Extra
- Gabby Soto
- Student / Extra
- Nora MacNeil
- Student / Extra
- Caroline Smith
- Student / Extra
- Hayley Calloway
- Student / Extra
- Emily Calloway
- Student / Extra
- Ethan Kraus
- Student / Extra
- Eleanor Greenbaum
- Student / Extra
- Jenna Panaro
- Student / Extra
- Brooke Vogel
- Student / Extra
- Justin Tan
- Student / Extra
- Deidre Winston
- Student / Extra
- Emily Azimi
- Student / Extra
- Nick Aguilar
- Student / Extra
- Neil Ruocco
- Student / Extra
- Michael Switzer
- Student / Extra
- Amanda Eppolito
- Student / Extra
- Stephanie Abramson
- Student / Extra
- Rose Baranowski
- Student / Extra
- Liz O'Hagen
- Student / Extra
- Bella Sirchia
- Student / Extra
- Nora McNeil
- Student / Extra
- Matthew Kushner
- Student / Extra
- Keely DeHavt
- Student / Extra
- Robert Dedvukaj
- Student / Extra
- Katie Jandrasits
- Student / Extra
- Mae Willman
- Student / Extra
- Mike Squitieri
- Student / Extra
- Joey Healy
- Student / Extra
- Abigail Brooks
- Student / Extra
- Cross Santaniello
- Student / Extra
- Joshau Stephen Adams
- Student / Extra
- William Mercado
- Student / Extra
- Emma Messenger
- Student / Extra
- Abbey Closson
- Student / Extra
- Kelsey Leary
- Student / Extra
- Nicole Giannetta
- Student / Extra
- Gabriella Soto
- Student / Extra
- Amanda Katsch
- Student / Extra
- Abigail Closson
- Student / Extra
- Tristan Iglesias
- Student / Extra
- Miguel Iglesias
- Student / Extra
- Patrick Marzella
- Student / Extra
- Robbie Conti
- Student / Extra
- Jade Creegan
- Student / Extra
- Thomas Hogan
- Student / Extra
- Kaitlyn Krug
- Student / Extra
- Courtney Wiggins
- Student / Extra
- Makeda Wiggins
- Student / Extra
- Kevin Whitmarsh
- Student / Extra
- Brian Alves
- Student / Extra
- Stacy Baker
- Victim
- Andrew Damon Henriques
- Customer
