- Ted Evans
- Â Ted 26 episodes, 2009-2014
- Kate Carson-Groner
- Â Amy 26 episodes, 2009-2014
- Michael Lippert
- Â Jay 24 episodes, 2009-2014
- Dan Hale
- Â Bill 22 episodes, 2009-2014
- Alex Harris
- Â Lockwood 20 episodes, 2009-2014
- Alix Klingenberg
- Â Beth 13 episodes, 2009-2014
- Keith Habersberger
- Â Dex 11 episodes, 2013-2014
- Matt Barnes
- Â Bar Guy / ... 9 episodes, 2009-2014
- Stevi Baston
- Â Callie 9 episodes, 2013-2014
- Jackelyn Normand
- Â Jackelyn (Actress) / ... 9 episodes, 2013-2014
- Katherine Schwartz
- Â Katherine (Actress) / ... 8 episodes, 2013-2014
- Ashley Bates
- Â Actress / ... 8 episodes, 2013-2014
- Sarah Hildreth
- Â Actress / ... 8 episodes, 2013-2014
- Ann Sonneville
- Â Veronica 7 episodes, 2013-2014
- Ellen Girvin
- Â Actress / ... 7 episodes, 2013-2014
- Mark Rosenthal
- Â Bar Guy / ... 6 episodes, 2011-2014
- Lindsay Bartlett
- Â Erica the Stage Manager / ... 6 episodes, 2011-2014
- Joel Kim Booster
- Â Charlie / ... 6 episodes, 2013-2014
- Tom Bambara
- Â Lt. Dan Actor 6 episodes, 2013-2014
- Emily Cooper
- Â Bar Girl / ... 6 episodes, 2013-2014
- Nick Mikula
- Â Rodrigo / ... 6 episodes, 2013-2014
- Cheryl Kujawinski
- Â Hottie Bartender 6 episodes, 2013-2014
- Nnamdi Ngwe
- Â Nnamdi (Bubba Actor) / ... 5 episodes, 2013-2014
- Nicole C. Hastings
- Â Ulya the Costume Designer 5 episodes, 2013-2014
- Trevor Martin
- Â Trevor (Actor) / ... 5 episodes, 2013-2014
- James 'Manny' Manno
- Â Assistant Director 4 episodes, 2013-2014
- Lance Wright
- Â Bar Guy 3 episodes, 2013-2014
- Patrick Hilton
- Â Bar Guy / ... 3 episodes, 2013-2014
- Ian Pfaff
- Â Carl / ... 2 episodes, 2009-2011
- Allison Yolo
- Â Ellen 2 episodes, 2009-2010
- Katey Selix
- Â Partygoer #2 / ... 2 episodes, 2009
- Lauran September
- Â Kickball Girl 2 episodes, 2011
- Tony LaRocca
- Â Bartender / ... 2 episodes, 2011
- Alex Peters
- Â Doppelganger Team Member #1 2 episodes, 2011
- Elise Mayfield
- Â Bar Girl 2 episodes, 2013-2014
- Laura L. Parris
- Â Bar Girl 2 episodes, 2013-2014
- Adina Kwasigroch
- Â Bar Girl 2 episodes, 2013-2014
- Eric Houtz
- Â Actor / ... 2 episodes, 2013-2014
- Brian Rooney
- Â Martin 2 episodes, 2013
- Kent Brickles
- Â Bar Guy 2 episodes, 2013
- Aaron Benham
- Â Accompianist 2 episodes, 2013
- Gabby Vaara
- Â Bar Girl 2 episodes, 2013
- Mary Hollis Inboden
- Â Geena 2 episodes, 2014
- Brian Wohl
- Â Fred 2 episodes, 2014
- Rob McLemore
- Â Yelling Guy 1 episode, 2009
- Michael Barry
- Â Craig 1 episode, 2010
- Christopher Markos
- Â Underground Gambler #2 1 episode, 2011
- Megan Captaine
- Â Kickball Fan 1 episode, 2011
- Sarah Montgomery
- Â Party Girl 1 episode, 2011
- Tim Konn
- Â Underground Gambler #1 1 episode, 2011
- Kera Evans
- Â Walking Girl #1 1 episode, 2011
- Aurelio Damiani
- Â Kickball Fan 1 episode, 2011
- Rick Arbizzani
- Â Car Thief 1 episode, 2011
- Steve Stein
- Â Underground Gambler #4 1 episode, 2011
- Jennifer Wiley
- Â Scorecard Girl 1 episode, 2011
- Cara Wolfe
- Â Walking Girl #2 1 episode, 2011
- Arnell Patscott
- Â Saluting Veteran 1 episode, 2011
- Steve Wood
- Â Underground Gambler #3 1 episode, 2011
- Julia Farmer
- Â Actress 1 episode, 2013
- Will Mobley
- Â Forrest Gump (voice) 1 episode, 2013
- Jeremy Chereskin
- Â Bar Guy 1 episode, 2013
- Missy Moreno
- Â Forrest's Mom (voice) 1 episode, 2013
- Lisa Witmer
- Â Karaoke Girl 1 episode, 2013
- Christina Flynn
- Â Actress 1 episode, 2013
- Loren Jones
- Â Fight Girl 1 episode, 2014
- Danielle Stahl
- Â Fight Girl 1 episode, 2014
- Stephanie Murphy
- Â Fight Girl 1 episode, 2014
- Diana Murphy
- Â Bar Patron 1 episode, 2014
- Ashleigh Ross
- Â Amber 1 episode, 2014
- Billy Montross
- Â Bar Guy 1 episode, 2014
- Krista D'Agostino
- Â Fight Girl 1 episode, 2014
- Brad Simanski
- Â Bar Patron 1 episode, 2014
- Laura Oleska
- Â Laura 1 episode, 2014
- Kim Fukawa
- Â Fight Girl 1 episode, 2014
- Christine Jennings
- Â Fight Girl 1 episode, 2014
