- Justina Valentine
- Self / Nonno / Nonna / Gianna / Network Exec / JV The Elf / JV33
- Darren 'Big Baby' Brand
- Self
- Royce Bell
- Store Clerk / Humble the Elf
- Gabby Blum
- Carmella
- Jonathan Sway Calloway
- Self
- Nick Cannon
- Self
- Tim Chantarangsu
- Self
- Corey Charron
- The Butler
- Conceited
- Self / Con The Elf
- Logan Cordts
- Young Carmella
- Eric D'Alessandro
- Johnny
- D.C. Young Fly
- Self
- Jay Garcia
- Miguel
- Teresa Giudice
- Self - The Guido Godmother
- Deanna Giulietti
- Angela
- Renee Graziano
- Self - The Fairy Mob Mother
- Vinny Guadagnino
- Self
- Perez Hilton
- Self
- Emmanuel Hudson
- Self
- Cortez Macklin
- Spencer's Store Clerk 2
- Lovely Mimi
- Publicist
- Susan Moses
- Aunt Sylvia
- Ocho Gr8
- Perez's Camera Guy
- DJ Suss One
- Self
- Belge Ortega
- Johnny's Date
- Vincent Pastore
- Mr. Sabino
- Brent Pella
- Tony - Brother
- Adrian Raio
- Lil Tony Jr
- Vin Rock
- Self
- Zoe Roe
- Izzy
- Shyla Skye Silva
- Carmella Friend Two
- Nick Singh
- Waiter
- Tonio Skits
- Tonio Skits (santa)
- Fatboy SSE
- Self
- Michael Taverna
- Joey
- Mike Taverna
- Joey
- Trey Twiz
- Self
- Fetty Wap
- Self
- Ally Chanel Watkins
- Carmella Friend One
- Chris Webby
- Self
