- Kaley Wheless
- Fran Ferguson
- Nick Offerman
- Narrator
- Martin Starr
- Mel
- Jennifer Prediger
- Stepmom
- Ella Dolan
- Parfait
- Mark Miller
- Grocery Store
- Jaley Shaner
- Jaley
- Jake French
- Jake
- Keith Poulson
- Nick
- Jack William Marshall
- Detective
- Dylan Cimbala
- Witness #1
- Yoko Lawing
- Detective
- Paul Sitzman
- Fan
- Sandy Booth
- Judge
- John Gatins
- Warden
- Ellyn Maranda Puckett
- Juror #7 / Pedestrian Slut Shamer (as Ellyn Puckett)
- Jina Maleksarkissians
- Fran's Lawyer
- Lance McDaniel
- Prison Guard
- Jesi Nelms
- Prison Guard #2
- Mayte Avina
- Prison Roommate
- Kim Nuss
- Music Teacher
- Emma Doxiadi
- Prisoner #2 / Community Service # 2 (as Emma Dioxiedi)
- Carl Rippy
- Divorce Judge
- Nate Bockus
- Uber Driver
- Bill Wise
- Parole Officer
- Kate Smith
- Sheila
- Mark Lammey
- Community Service #1
- Zefrey Throwell
- Community Service Leader
- David Krumholtz
- Group Therapy Leader
- Jack Henry Robbins
- Jonah
- Emmy Harrington
- Piper
- Megan Jerabek
- Carmen
- Kellen Mays
- Eli
- Dickson McGuire
- Dentist
- Dante Harper
- Cognitive Behavioral Therapist
