- Myles Clohessy
- Animal Al / Ananias
- Robert Clohessy
- Moe The Book
- Julianna Layne
- Alicia / Alesha
- Bridget White
- Elisabeth
- Brian Anthony Wilson
- Father Tom Higgins / Raphael
- Gabi Faye
- GiGi / Gislenus
- Greg Nutcher
- Nick
- Connor Christie
- Mikey
- Byron Clohessy
- Manny / Melchior
- Shannan Wilson
- Maureen / Martina
- Avery McGee
- Tina / Celestina
- Zoë Bowen Smith
- Mare / Mary
- Madison Schwartz
- Little Maureen / Little Martina
- Dominic Costa
- Roadkill / Romulus
- Henry Gagliardi
- Gilbert / Gus
- Corrie Graham
- Sister Regina / Amita Hortensia
- Rich Henkels
- Dr. Galena / Dr. Gallo
- Kevin D. Benton
- Bobby
- Gianna Gagliardi
- Brittany
