- Brielle Carter
- Elfette
- Quinton Aaron
- Santa Claus
- George Vricos
- Little Georgie
- Alea Figueroa
- Sparkle
- Christian Cashmir
- Duey
- Sean Keller
- Bartholomule
- Christopher Cutillo
- Goon
- Anaïs Blake
- Sebastian
- Sheli Sanders
- Penelope Coalbottom
- Kenneth McGregor
- Georgie's Dad
- Nicole Stefansic
- Mrs. Claus
- Michele Young
- Duey's Mom
- Gina Zicchino
- Elf Boss
- BobbyAnn Loper
- Elly
- Daryen Ratte
- Elvira
- Becki Mallett
- Elfmandu
- Austin Janowsky
- Male Elf
- Ashleigh Blackburn
- Design Elf
- Katherine Zanders
- Frozen Elf #1
- Avery McKenna
- Frozen Elf #2
- Shaila Velazquez
- Elf
- Daniella Paris Greco
- The North Pole Receptionist
- Midge Mamatas
- Pencil Phone Grandma
- Denise Durette
- Pencil Phone Woman
- Yao Tsai
- Pencil Phone Man
- John Banker
- Pencil Phone Young Man / Cop #2
- Skyler Pursifull
- Pencil Phone Young Woman #1
- Tetiana Cashmir
- Pencil Phone Model
- Renato Galaz-Aranguiz
- Pencil Phone Young Boy
- Lennon Brock
- Young Girl
- Estelle Brock
- Young Girl's Mom
- Anthony Brock
- Young Girl's Dad
- Raige Brock
- Young Boy
- Jann Van Dyke
- Board Member
- Jeff Shepard
- JoyTech Analyst
- Buzz Van Dyke
- Board Member
- Jai Jacob
- JoyTech Security
- Dejon Prade
- Beach Bartender
- Josh Martin
- Salesman Bumbatical
- Alan Daniels
- Red Haired Thug
- Keith Norstein
- Diner Customer
- Alison Burns
- Blanche The Mall Elf
- Harla Briggs
- Sparkle's Mom
- Joshua Quincey
- Warehouse Worker
- Scott Sullivan
- Shady Trucker
- Ashley Schratz
- Da Sesto Waitress
- Neil Gerbe
- Ms. Coalbottom's Chauffeur
- Sesto Ramadori
- Da Sesto Doorman
- Jared Miller
- New York Telegram Guy
- Jeremy Westrate
- Pebble-Fellow Tree Security
- John Lescarbeau
- Jewelry Store Appraiser
- Briston George
- CIA Agent #1
- Mark Purvis
- CIA Agent #2
- Zachary Vazquez
- Ernest Killingsworth III
