- Bill Alfonso
- Self
- Bam Bam Bigelow
- Self - The Triple Threat
- Terry Brunk
- Sabu
- Mike Bucci
- Super Nova
- Chris Candido
- Self - The Triple Threat
- Lou D'angeli
- Sign Guy Dudley - The Dudley Boys
- Shane Douglas
- Self - The Triple Threat
- Tommy Dreamer
- Self
- Anthony Durante
- Pitbull #2
- Francine Fournier
- Francine - The Triple Threat
- Jim Fullington
- The Sandman
- Doug Furnas
- Self
- Joel Gertner
- Self - The Dudley Boys
- Trisa Hayes
- Beulah McGillicutty
- Brian Heffron
- The Blue Meanie
- Devon Hughes
- D-Von Dudley - The Dudley Boys
- Matt Hyson
- Spike Dudley
- Jeff Jones
- Self - referee
- Jason Knight
- Jason
- Brian Knighton
- Axl Rotten
- John Kronus
- Self
- Phillip LaFon
- Self
- Loren W. Lepre
- Infamous Sabu Fan
- Mark LoMonaco
- Buh Buh Ray Dudley - The Dudley Boys
- Jerry Lynn
- Self
- James Maritato
- Little Guido - The FBI
- Jim Molineaux
- Self - Referee
- P.J. Polaco
- Justin Credible
- Jonathan Rechner
- Balls Mahoney
- Tommy Rich
- Self - The FBI
- Alex Rizzo
- Big Dick Dudley - The Dudley Boys
- Peter Senerchia
- Taz
- Tracy Smothers
- Self - The FBI
- Lance Storm
- Self
- Joey Styles
- Self - commentator
- Rob Van Dam
- Self
- Mikey Whipwreck
- Self
- Gary Wolf
- Pitbull #1
- Lance Wright
- Self
- Jerome Young
- New Jack
