- Donald O'Connor
- Davey Crandall
- Helena Carter
- Lady Sylvia Copeland
- Will Geer
- Tom Botts
- John Emery
- Gov. Elden
- Stanley Logan
- Lord Montrose
- Kathryn Givney
- Lady Montrose
- Hayden Rorke
- Malcolm Giles
- Morgan Farley
- Caleb Nicholas
- Robert Barrat
- Henry Morgan
- Alan Napier
- Capt. Kidd
- Glenn Strange
- Capt. Ben Avery
- Louis Bacigalupi
- Blackbeard
- Hope Emerson
- Mistress Ann Bonney
- Charles McGraw
- Capt. Ben Wickett
- James Arness
- Bullock
- Paul Bradley
- Party Guest
- George Bruggeman
- Ship Crewman
- Ralph Byrd
- Will
- Albert Cavens
- Pirate
- Jeff Chandler
- Narrator
- Martin Cichy
- Tavern Patron
- Bud Cokes
- Sailor
- Helen Dickson
- Party Guest
- Jimmy Dime
- Tavern Patron
- William Fawcett
- Guard
- Clem Fuller
- Member of King's Guard
- Chuck Hamilton
- Pirate
- Chester Jones
- Servant
- J.M. Kerrigan
- Debtor
- Ethan Laidlaw
- Pirate
- Gregg Martell
- Issac Wells
- Robert Milasch
- Tavern Patron
- Charles Morton
- Tavern Patron
- Gavin Muir
- British Sea Captain
- Jack Perry
- Tavern Patron
- Frank Puglia
- Debtor
- Harry Raven
- Pirate
- John Rice
- Pirate
- Frank Richards
- Tavern Bouncer
- Leoda Richards
- Party Guest
- Suzanne Ridgway
- Tavern Girl
- Victor Romito
- Pirate
- John Roy
- Tavern Patron
- Mickey Simpson
- Pirate
- Cap Somers
- Tavern Patron
- Ray Spiker
- Pirate
- Harry Wilson
- Pirate
