- Tom Sizemore
- Knicks
- Evalena Marie
- Zib
- Rick Ravanello
- Damon
- Anthony Del Negro
- Tommy
- Adrienne LaValley
- Maya
- Kevin Shea
- Father Tito
- Greg Nutcher
- Father Leeds
- Kerry McGann
- Mother Leeds
- John Swanson
- Old Priest
- Caitlin Zoz
- Midwife
- Alex Kip
- Young Priest
- Murphy Betancourt
- Curly Hair
- Kealani Marie
- Dani
- Jeff Orens
- Corley
- Drew Torres
- Frank
- Korey Fackler
- Blue Eyes / Glasses (as Dizzle Fackler)
- Bruce Betancourt
- Ponytail
- Sean Gallimore
- Clean Cut
- Tasia A. Jones
- Redhead
- Matt Healey
- Brawny
- Timm Wims
- Shotgun
- Manny Ayala
- Goatee
- Ronin James
- Glasses
- Paul Melluzzo
- Driver Bro
- Peter Misluk
- Passenger Bro
- Jacqui Denski
- Diner Waitress
- Paul Drechsler-Martell
- Crooked Tooth
- Kevin Kate
- Middle-Aged Priest
- Chris Dyer
- Freckles
- Ben Chester
- Jersey Devil
- Brett Lapeyrouse
- Bally Leader
- Shannon Siedzik
- Halo Sister
- Erica Joseph Hunter
- Woman at Gas Station
- Aaron M. Larkin
- Burly Local
- Austin Fiszel
- Gas Station Customer
- Jennifer Maudsley
- Gas Station Customer
- Estelle Mikayla
- Infant Zib
- Brandon McClary
- Strong Jaw
- Anthony Hoang
- Crew Cut
- John Doolan
- Dreadlocks
- Elizabeth Verrill
- Dyed Hair
- Jeremy Rosengrant
- Large Man
- Timothy Markiewicz
- Man at Train Station
- Mike Sobieniak Jr.
- Driver
- Torrey Benane
- Additional Keeper
- Kate Billard
- Additional Keeper
- Charles 'Buddy' Buder
- Additional Keeper
- Stephen Culjak Jr.
- Additional Keeper
- Kyle Durand
- Additional Keeper
- John Stephen Kelley
- Additional Keeper
- Bryan Kopp
- Additional Keeper
- Mitchell L. Mack
- Additional Keeper
- Steven A. Miller
- Additional Keeper
- Karen Moyle
- Additional Keeper
- Gregory Norsigian
- Additional Keeper
- Zach O'Brien
- Additional Keeper
- Stephon Reynolds
- Additional Keeper
- Ty Stone
- Additional Keeper
- Troy Walcott
- Additional Keeper
- Jae Greene
- Glasses
