- Chelsea Vale
- Adrianna
- Tom Sizemore
- Sheriff Walsh
- Robert LaSardo
- Victor
- Michael Madsen
- Damon
- Tommy Dreamer
- Tommy Flanagan
- Hannah Dannelly
- Tina
- Sully Erna
- Kevin Price
- Tom DeNucci
- Johnny
- Christopher C. Romero
- Tocho
- Forest Quaglia
- Zack
- Chris Whitcomb
- Javon
- Alec Nevin
- Spencer
- Alessandria Greene
- Sonja
- David Gere
- Mr. Greene
- Joey Ambrosini
- Perry
- Kurita
- Tora
- Claudio Orefice
- Captain Peters
- Daniel Jacobi
- Billy Horton
- Curtis Edwards
- Kitchi
- June Hargrove
- Mato
- Erik Bloomquist
- Detective Morgan
- Jim Vitale
- Masked Damon
- Gia Stanco
- Waitress
- Sue Velasquez
- Tora's Mother
- Eric Weinstock
- Detective Henry
- Talia Weinstock
- Claire
- Toby Weinstock
- Denise
- Chris Baldyga
- Police Officer
- Greg Bereski Jr.
- Police Officer
- A.J. Bernardo
- Ricky (Burial Ground Massacre)
- Carson Bloomquist
- Bartender
- Dean Brown
- Helicopter Pilot
- Keont'e Collins
- Bar Patron
- Bob Dio
- Crime Scene Photographer
- Edward Dirgo
- Bar Patron
- Sama Fernands
- Princess Aiyana (Burial Ground Massacre)
- Sandra L. Fogell
- Bar Patron
- Danielle Francine
- Patron
- Savannah Giammarco
- News Reporter
- Travis Gordon
- Eddie (Burial Ground Massacre)
- Tony Grano
- Police Officer
- Kara Curnane Joseph
- Becky (Burial Ground Massacre)
- Jason Longo
- Police Station Inmate
- Mitchell Maknis
- Patron
- Vinny Marseglia
- Masked Damon (Burial Ground Massacre)
- Alessandro Molluzzo
- Waiter
- Blaise Serra
- Chase (Burial Ground Massacre)
- Jackson Gower Taylor
- Bar Patron
- Brittany Toczko
- Kayla (Burial Ground Massacre)
- Laura Towne
- Bar Patron
- Chad Verdi Jr.
- Patron
