- Tab Hunter
- Joe Hardy
- Gwen Verdon
- Lola
- Ray Walston
- Mr. Applegate
- Russ Brown
- Benny Van Buren
- Shannon Bolin
- Mrs. Meg Boyd
- Nathaniel Frey
- Smokey
- James Komack
- Rocky
- Rae Allen
- Gloria Thorpe
- Robert Shafer
- Joe Boyd
- Jean Stapleton
- Sister Miller
- Albert Linville
- Vernon
- Roy Sievers
- Joe Hardy - #2 - Washington Senators
- William Adams
- Yankees Team Owner
- Phil Arnold
- Newsstand Proprietor
- Robert Banas
- Baseball Player
- Benjie Bancroft
- Trial Spectator
- John Barton
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Yogi Berra
- Self - New York Yankee
- Rodney Bieber
- Baseball Player
- Herman Boden
- Baseball Player / Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)
- Nesdon Booth
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Jack Carr
- Man denying scandal
- Allen Case
- Baseball Player
- Dick Cherney
- Baseball Player
- Fred Curt
- Baseball Player
- Pepe J. DeChiazza
- Baseball Player
- William Fawcett
- Postmaster Hawkins
- Roy Fitzell
- Baseball Player
- George Ford
- Trial Spectator
- Bob Fosse
- Mambo Dancer
- Joseph Glick
- Baseball Game Spectator
- James Gonzalez
- Reporter
- Herschel Graham
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Jack Henderson
- Theater Spectator
- Stuart Holmes
- Backstage Extra
- Elizabeth Howell
- Doris Miller
- Bruce Hoy
- Baseball Player
- Perk Lazelle
- Trial Spectator
- Mickey Mantle
- Self - New York Yankee
- John Marlin
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Mathew McCue
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Joseph Mell
- Reporter
- Mike Morelli
- Theater Spectator
- Sol Murgi
- Pedestrian
- Art Passarella
- Umpire
- Joseph Paz
- Man Buying Newspaper
- Frank Radcliffe
- Baseball Player
- John Roy
- Trial Spectator
- Jeffrey Sayre
- Reporter
- Frank J. Scannell
- Reporter
- Bernard Sell
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Lucile Sewall
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Fred Sherman
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Moose Skowron
- Self - New York Yankee
- Norman Stevans
- Trial Spectator
- Robert Strong
- Reporter
- Arthur Tovey
- Man Buying Newspaper
- Jack Tygett
- Baseball Player
- Ralph Volkie
- Baseball Game Spectator
- Harry Wilson
- Theater Spectator
- Judith Woodbury
- Trial Spectator
