- Peter Falk
- Dino
- Dianne Wiest
- Lenore
- Emily Lloyd
- Cookie
- Michael V. Gazzo
- Carmine
- Brenda Vaccaro
- Bunny
- Adrian Pasdar
- Vito
- Lionel Stander
- Enzo Della Testa
- Jerry Lewis
- Arnold Ross
- Bob Gunton
- Segretto
- Benjamin Rayson
- Henry Solomon
- Ricki Lake
- Pia
- Joe Mantello
- Dominick
- Thomas Quinn
- Vinnie
- David Wohl
- Alvin Diamond
- Joy Behar
- Dottie
- Frank Gio
- Frankie
- Mario Todisco
- Sloppy Louie
- Tony LaFortezza
- Angelo
- Rockets Redglare
- Carmine's Wiseguy
- Anthony Powers
- Carmine's Wiseguy
- Tony Sirico
- Carmine's Wiseguy
- Frank Aquilino
- Dino's Wiseguy
- Clem Caserta
- Dino's Wiseguy
- Mike Marino
- Dino's Wiseguy
- Jim Mauro
- Dino's Wiseguy
- Guido Innacelli
- Dino's Wiseguy
- F.X. Vitolo
- Motorcycle Cop
- Ira Flitter
- State Trooper
- Joe Pentangelo
- Federal Agent #1
- David Reilly
- Federal Agent #2
- William Jay Marshall
- Frank Pearl
- George Bartenieff
- Andy O'Brien
- Ed Setrakian
- Mike Fusco
- Paul Slimak
- Priest
- Sydney Sheriff
- Salesman
- Mark Boone Junior
- Transit Cop
- Arto Lindsay
- Court Clerk
- Ralph Monaco
- Judge
- Evan Bell
- Court Guard
- Kim Chan
- Hong Kong Tailor
- Marshall Anker
- Parole Board Member
- Aida Linares
- Carmen
- Delphi Harrington
- Rosa Tarantino
- Margaret Knopf
- Recipe Woman
- Crystal Field
- Angela
- J.D. DeKranis
- Cookie's Friend
- J.P.
- Cookie's Friend
- Alfred De La Fuente
- Maitre D'
- Lynne White
- TV Reporter
- Teresa Bellettieri
- Vito's Girlfriend
- Isabell O'Connor
- Matron
- Richard Caselnova
- Driver
- Tony Devon
- Bodyguard
- Steve DeLuca
- Bomb Squad Man
- Ben Spell
- Justice of the Peace
- Jerry Blavat
- D.J. at Chateau Mer
- Bob Martana
- Ritz Truck Driver
- Marv Albert
- The Voice of the New York Knicks
- Mario Biazzo
- Waiter
- Matthew T. Gitkin
- Street Person
- Stefanie Marco
- Madonna Wannabe
- Barry Squitieri
- Angelo Rosselo / Dino's Wiseguy (uncredited)
