- Loretta Young
- Sister Margaret
- Celeste Holm
- Sister Scholastica
- Hugh Marlowe
- Robert 'Bob' Mason
- Elsa Lanchester
- Amelia Potts
- Thomas Gomez
- Luigi Rossi
- Dorothy Patrick
- Kitty Blaine
- Basil Ruysdael
- The Bishop
- Dooley Wilson
- Anthony James
- Regis Toomey
- Monsignor Talbot
- Mike Mazurki
- Sam
- Walter Baldwin
- Claude Jarman - Realtor
- Pati Behrs
- Nun
- John Bleifer
- Rosey - Rossi's Goon
- Nan Boardman
- Nun
- Wally Brown
- Howard Sheldon - Bob's Agent
- Russ Clark
- Policeman
- Louise Colombet
- Nun
- Teddy Driver
- Cherub
- Georgette Duane
- Nun
- Robert Foulk
- New York City Policeman
- Gordon Gebert
- Willie Matthews
- Eula Guy
- Mrs. O'Connor
- Louis Jean Heydt
- Al Newman
- Tim Huntley
- Buzz Townsend-Cooper
- Danny Jackson
- George - Jarman's Assistant
- Geraldine Jordan
- Woman
- Virginia Keiley
- Mrs. Townsend-Cooper
- Nolan Leary
- Bethlehem Station Master
- Henri Letondal
- Father Barraud
- Ian MacDonald
- Mr. Matthews
- Marion Martin
- Rossi's Manicurist
- Edwin Max
- Whitey - Rossi's Associate
- Roddy McCaskill
- Cherub
- Gary Pagett
- Johnnie Matthews
- Jean Prescott
- Mrs. Matthews
- Yvette Reynard
- Nun
- Frank Richards
- Lefty - Rossi's Goon
- Loulette Sablon
- Nun
