- Olegar Fedoro
- Christopher Columbus
- Alvaro Martin
- Ferdinand Columbus
- David Sant
- Bartolome Columbus
- Javier Mazan
- Francisco de Porras
- Ivan de Lucas
- Diego de Porras
- Carlos J. de la Torre
- Diego Mendez
- Edward Herrmann
- Self - Narrator
- Martin Dugard
- Self
- Lynne Guitar
- Self - Historian, Dominican Republic
- Mark Horton
- Self - University of Bristol
- Felix Bachmann Quadros
- Spanish Sailor
- Osvaldo Barrera
- Indian
- Dante Concha
- Indian
- Denis Crampton
- Chief Quibian
- Richard Fish
- Spanish Fighter
- Robert Salvidge
- Skipper
- Adam Schuch-des Forges
- Spanish Fighter
- Daniel Stokes
- Governor Nicolas Ovando
- José Vásquez
- Indian
