- Sara Amato
- Sara Del Rey
- Claudio Castagnoli
- Self
- James Cipperly
- Fire Ant
- Jose Cordero
- Lince Dorado
- Crossbones
- Self
- Nicolas Dansereau
- Player Uno
- Delirious
- Delirious
- Bobby Dempsey
- Self
- Andrew Dinsmore
- Hydra
- Marc Dionne
- Player Dos
- Tim Donst
- Self
- Jack Dourakos
- Louden Noxious
- Dr. Cube
- Self
- El Hijo del Ice Cream
- Self
- Vin Gerard
- Self
- Robert Goodwin
- Hallowicked
- Ronald Grams
- Icarus
- Shayne Hawke
- Buck Hawke
- Dustin Howard
- Chuck Taylor
- Jon Huber
- Brodie Lee
- Ice Cream Jr.
- Self
- Edward Jones
- Gran Akuma
- Edward Moore
- Eddie Kingston
- Jimmy Olsen
- Self
- Ophidian
- Self
- Desean Pratt
- Amasis
- Bryce Remsburg
- Self
- Mitch Ryder
- Self
- Mike Spillane
- Mike Quackenbush
- Joseph R. Sposto
- Leonard F. Chikarason
- Larry Sweeney
- Larry Sweeney
- Nick Tygielski
- Nick Papagiorgio
- Ultramantis Black
- Self
- Worker Ant
- Self
- Drake Wuertz
- Drake Younger
