- Claudio Castagnoli
- Claudio Castagnoli
- Jon Huber
- Brodie Lee - The Roughnecks
- James Cipperly
- Fire Ant - The Colony
- Edward Moore
- Eddie Kingston
- Yujiro Kushida
- Self
- Dustin Howard
- Chuck Taylor - Team F.I.S.T.
- Trevor Mann
- Helios- The Future Is Now
- Drew Gulak
- Soldier Ant - The Colony
- Nicolas Dansereau
- Player Uno- The Super Smash Brothers
- Bryan Danielson
- Self - Team Uppercut
- Rami Sebei
- El Generico
- Nick Massie
- Nick Jackson- The Young Bucks
- Kota Ibushi
- Self
- Daniel Solwold
- Austin Aries
- Matt Menard
- Brad Badd
- Al Snow
- Self - The Cold Front
- Tracy Williams
- Green Ant - The Colony / Dieter VonSteigerwalt - The BDK
- A.C. Connor
- D-Lo Brown- The Cold Front
- Sara Amato
- Sara Del Rey
- Marc Dionne
- Player Dos- The Super Smash Brothers
- Johnny Saint
- Self - The Masters of a Thousand Holds
- Ray Lloyd
- Glacier- The Cold Front
- Bryce Remsburg
- Self
- Jose Cordero
- Lince Dorado- The Future Is Now
- Dave Taylor
- Self - Team Uppercut
- Jeff Parker
- Chad Badd- The Badd Boys
- Jonathan Barber
- Self - referee
- Arik Cannon
- Self - The F1RST Family
- Chizzy
- Self
- Darin Corbin
- Self - The North Star Express / The F1RST Family (archive footage)
- Crossbones
- Self - The Order of the Neo-Solar Temple
- Ryan Cruz
- Self - The North Star Express / The F1RST Family (archive footage)
- Colin Delaney
- Self - The UnStable
- Stephen Delicato
- Frightmare- Incoherence
- Delirious
- Delirious- Incoherence / The Order of the Neo-Solar Temple (as William Hunter Johnston)
- Tim Donst
- Self / Vökoder- The Order of the Neo-Solar Temple
- Jack Dourakos
- Louden Noxious- commentator / ring announcer
- Sugar Dunkerton
- Self - The Throwbacks
- Dymond
- Self - Da Soul Touchaz
- Atsuko Emoto
- Bullfight Sora
- Escorpion Egipcio
- Self - The Osirian Portal
- Vin Gerard
- Self - The UnStable
- Robert Goodwin
- Hallowicked- Incoherence
- Ronald Grams
- Icarus- Team F.I.S.T.
- Dasher Hatfield
- Self - The Throwbacks
- Marco Jaggi
- Ares- The BDK
- Edward Jones
- Gran Akuma- Team F.I.S.T.
- Matt Krizovensky
- Grizzly Redwood
- Ed McGuckin
- Jigsaw- The Future Is Now
- Jimmy Olsen
- Jimmy Equinox Olsen- The Future Is Now / commentator
- Ophidian
- Self - The Osirian Portal
- Adam Ortega
- Carpenter Ant- The Colony / Pinkie Sanchez
- Desean Pratt
- Amasis- The Osirian Portal
- Willie Richardson
- Self - Da Soul Touchaz
- Jorge Riviera
- Jorge Skayde Riviera
- Marshe Rockett
- Self - Da Soul Touchaz
- Emily Sharp
- Self
- Yuki Shiraishi
- Nikkan Lee- referee
- Mike Spillane
- Mike Quackenbush
- Joseph R. Sposto
- Leonard F. Chikarason- commentator
- Shannon Spruill
- Shark Girl
- Stigma
- Self - The UnStable
- Tursas
- Self - The BDK
- Nick Tygielski
- Nick Papageorgio- referee
- Ultramantis Black
- Self - The Order of the Neo-Solar Temple
- Jay Washington
- Trauma- Da Soul Touchaz
- Wiggly
- Self
- Sean Young
- C-Red- Da Soul Touchaz
- Jakob Hammermeier
- CHIKARA Wrestle Factory student
