- Mark Angelosetti
- 'Mr. Touchdown' Mark Angelosetti- The Throwbacks
- Argus
- Self
- R.B. Banks
- Missile Assault Man- Battleborn
- Sean Burke
- Flex Rumblecrunch- The Devastation Corporation
- Lucas Calhoun
- 'Juke Joint' Lucas Calhoun- Battleborn
- James Cipperly
- Fire Ant - The Colony
- Stephen Delicato
- Frightmare- The Nightmare Warriors
- Dr. Rod Diamondfire
- Self - commentator
- Chris Estrada
- Obariyon- The Batiri
- Kimberly Frankele
- Princess Kimberlee
- Robert Goodwin
- Hallowicked- The Nightmare Warriors
- Ronald Grams
- Icarus
- Jakob Hammermeier
- Self - Die Bruderschaft des Kreuzes
- Dasher Hatfield
- Self - The Throwbacks
- Stokely Hathaway
- Chuck Taylor TM
- Kobald
- Self - The Batiri
- Jonny Mangue
- Jaka- Die Bruderschaft des Kreuzes
- Edward Moore
- Eddie Kingston
- Ophidian
- Self - The Snake Pit
- Adam Ortega
- Pinkie Sanchez- Die Bruderschaft des Kreuzes
- Joe Padilla
- Juan Francisco de Coronado
- Larry Peace
- Self - referee
- Dori Elizabeth Prange
- Heidi Lovelace
- Desean Pratt
- Amasis
- Proletariat Boar of Moldova
- Self
- Vlad Radinov
- Self - ring announcer
- Bryce Remsburg
- Bryce Remsburg
- Louie Rodriguez
- Kodama- The Batiri
- Ian Sison
- Wani
- Mike Spillane
- Mike Quackenbush - Commentator
- Josh Thorman
- Oleg the Usurper
- Shyn Ron
- Shynron- The Snake Pit
