- Mark Angelosetti
- 'Mr. Touchdown' Mark Angelosetti- The Throwbacks / Dasher's Dugout
- Argus
- Self - The Snake Pit
- James Cipperly
- Orange Cassidy / Fire Ant
- Stephen Delicato
- Frightmare- The Nightmare Warriors
- El Hijo del Ice Cream
- Self - Los Ice Creams / Crown and Court
- Dasher Hatfield
- Self - The Throwbacks / Dasher's Dugout
- Ice Cream Jr.
- Self - Los Ice Creams / Crown and Court
- Joe Padilla
- Juan Francisco de Coronado- The United Nations
- Desean Pratt
- Amasis- Battle Hive
- Proletariat Boar of Moldova
- Self - The Bloc Party / The United Nations
- Bryce Remsburg
- Bryce Remsburg
- Derek Sabato
- Self - referee
- Mike Spillane
- Mike Quackenbush - Commentator
- Swamp Monster
- Self - The Gentleman's Club
- Josh Thorman
- Oleg the Usurper- The Arcane Horde
- Timothy P. Vassa
- Blind Rage- The Nightmare Warriors
