- AJ Styles
- Self - BULLET CLUB
- Matt Massie
- Matt Jackson- BULLET CLUB
- Nick Massie
- Nick Jackson- BULLET CLUB
- Fenix
- Fenix - Team AAA
- James Cipperly
- Orange Cassidy / Fire Ant (as Orange Cassidy)
- Edward Moore
- Eddie Kingston - The Snake Pit
- Dori Elizabeth Prange
- Heidi Lovelace- Dasher's Dugout
- Dustin Howard
- Mr. Azerbaijan - The United Nations / Chuck Taylor- The Gentleman's Club
- Drew Gulak
- Self - The Gentleman's Club
- Pete Dunne
- Pete Dunne - Team ATTACK
- Sean Waltman
- Self - commentator
- Brian Heffron
- The Blue Meanie - The Blue World Order
- Mark Andrews
- Self - Team ATTACK
- Mark Angelosetti
- 'Mr. Touchdown' Mark Angelosetti- Dasher's Dugout
- R.B. Banks
- Missile Assault Man- Battleborn
- Tyler Bate
- Self - Team Fight Club: PRO
- Alexander Bird
- Self - Battleborn
- Mike Bucci
- Hollywood Nova- The Blue World Order
- Sean Burke
- Flex Rumblecrunch- The Devastation Corporation
- Lucas Calhoun
- 'Juke Joint' Lucas Calhoun- Battleborn
- Kevin Condron
- Self - Battleborn / Jervis Cottonbelly- Crown and Court
- Stephen Delicato
- Frightmare- The Nightmare Warriors
- Joey Eastman
- Sidney Bakabella
- El Hijo del Ice Cream
- Self - Crown and Court
- Chris Estrada
- Obariyon- The Arcane Horde
- Kimberly Frankele
- Princess Kimberlee - Crown and Court
- Robert Goodwin
- Hallowicked- The Nightmare Warriors
- Ronald Grams
- Icarus- Dasher's Dugout
- Jakob Hammermeier
- Self - Die Bruderschaft des Kreuzes
- Dasher Hatfield
- Self - Dasher's Dugout
- Ice Cream Jr.
- Self - Crown and Court
- Troy Magalhaes
- Nokken- Die Bruderschaft des Kreuzes
- Michael Manna
- Stevie Richards- The Blue World Order
- Dan Moloney
- Self - Team Fight Club: PRO
- Ophidian
- Self - The Snake Pit
- Adam Ortega
- Pinkie Sanchez- Die Bruderschaft des Kreuzes
- Nelson Ortiz
- Worker Ant- Battle Hive
- Joe Padilla
- Juan Francisco de Coronado- The United Nations
- Desean Pratt
- Pharaoh Ant- Battle Hive
- Proletariat Boar of Moldova
- Self - The United Nations
- Sebastian Reese
- Max Smashmaster- The Devastation Corporation
- Bryce Remsburg
- Bryce Remsburg
- Louie Rodriguez
- Kodama- The Arcane Horde
- Prakash Sabar
- Self - The United Nations
- Derek Sabato
- Self - referee
- Trent Seven
- Trent Seven- Team Fight Club: PRO
- Victor Soto
- Drago- Team AAA
- Mike Spillane
- Mike Quackenbush - Commentator
- Joseph R. Sposto
- Leonard F. Chikarason- commentator
- Aero Star
- Self - Team AAA
- Thomas Stintsman
- Blaster McMassive- The Devastation Corporation
- Swamp Monster
- Self - The Gentleman's Club
- Josh Thorman
- Oleg the Usurper- The Arcane Horde
- Ultramantis Black
- UltraMantis Black - The Arcane Horde
- Shyn Ron
- Shynron- The Snake Pit
- Morgan Webster
- Self - Team ATTACK
- Tracy Williams
- Silver Ant- The Nightmare Warriors
