- Jonathan Barber
- Self - referee
- Preston Blathers
- Self - ring announcer
- Cajun Crawdad
- Self - The Creatures of the Deep
- Lucas Calhoun
- 'Juke Joint' Lucas Calhoun
- Callux the Castigator
- Self - The Proteus Wheel
- James Cipperly
- Fire Ant - The Colony
- Drew Cordeiro
- Denver Colorado- commentator
- Solo Darling
- Self - commentator
- Tony Deppen
- Self - Team F.I.S.T.
- Dr. Rod Diamondfire
- Self - commentator
- Chris Dickinson
- Chris Dickinson
- Axel Ford
- Self
- Frantik
- Frantik- The Proteus Wheel
- Ryan Galeone
- Self - Team Beyond Wrestling
- Robert Goodwin
- Hallowicked- Team CHIKARA
- Ronald Grams
- Icarus- Team CHIKARA
- Green Ant
- Self - The Colony
- Boomer Hatfield
- Self - Team CHIKARA
- Dasher Hatfield
- Self - Team CHIKARA
- Hermit Crab
- Self - The Creatures of the Deep
- Scott Holladay
- Self - interviewer
- Travis Huckabee
- Self - Team F.I.S.T.
- Brian Milonas
- Self - Team Beyond Wrestling
- Ophidian
- Self
- Joe Padilla
- Juan Francisco de Coronado- Team CHIKARA
- Professor Nicodemus
- Self - The Proteus Wheel
- Proletariat Boar of Moldova
- Self - Team CHIKARA
- Razerwyng
- Razerhawk - Xyberhawx 2000
- Bryce Remsburg
- Bryce Remsburg
- John Silver
- Self - Team Beyond Wrestling
- Mike Spillane
- Mike Quackenbush- commentator
- Thief Ant
- Self - The Colony
- Ultramantis Black
- Self - Team CHIKARA
- Volgar
- Self - The Proteus Wheel
- Ashley Vox
- Oceanea- The Creatures of the Deep
- The Whisper
- Self - commentator
- Nick Wilson
- Nick Gage- Team Beyond Wrestling
- Cameron Zagami
- Cam Zagami- Team Beyond Wrestling
- Alex Zikos
- Alex Reynolds- Team Beyond Wrestling
