- Rebecca Rinehart
- Woman in Peril
- Blair Kelly
- Mal (Segment: Of Cats and Men)
- Joshua Gotte
- Brandon (Segment: Of Cats and Men)
- Erica Rowell Green
- Tonya (Segment: Of Cats and Men)
- William Buster Benefield
- Bill (Segment: Of Cats and Men)
- Annie Ruth Hughes
- Catnado Witness
- Serena Salieri
- Gracie (Segment: The Catburglar)
- Melvin Pittman
- Detective Richards (Segment: The Catburglar)
- Mitchell Rhodes
- Detective Simmonds (Segment: The Catburglar)
- Jonathan Dixon
- Norman Oaks (Segment: The Catburglar)
- Blake Blasko
- Gremlin (Segment: Nightmare at 10000 Feet)
- Juan K. Wilson
- Detective Quaid (Segment: The Catburglar)
- Julian Betts
- Julian (Segment: Nightmare at 10000 Feet)
- William Lewis IV
- Wish (Segment: Nightmare at 10000 Feet)
- Josh Ward
- Oliver (Segment: Apocalypse Meow)
- Jesse Welch
- Jerry (Segment: Apocalypse Meow)
- Tim Ritter
- Louis (Segment: Crimes and Felines)
- Shannon Stockin
- Irena (Segment: Crimes and Felines)
- Jason Boyd
- Kent (Segment: Crimes and Felines)
- Katrina
- Nastasia (Segment: Crimes and Felines)
- Tucky Williams
- Queen of the Galaxy (Segment: Cosmic Catnado)
- Jerry Williams
- Astro the Space Hero (Segment: Cosmic Catnado)
- Lola Magdalene Scott
- Vespa (Segment: Cosmic Catnado)
- Matt Enstrom
- Admiral Kepler (Segment: Cosmic Catnado)
- Henry Umble
- Admiral Morris (Segment: Cosmic Catnado)
- Mark Holmberg
- Java Jones (Segment: Cosmic Catnado)
- Todd Burrows
- That Guy (Segment: Cosmic Catnado)
- Milly Franklin Thomas
- Narcissa (Segment: Cosmic Catnado)
- Vickie Vicious
- News Fury (Segment: Cosmic Catnado)
- Curtis Everitt
- Curtis (Segment: Storm Window)
