- John Payne
- Dick Lindsay / Robert MacAllister
- Arlene Dahl
- Christine MacAllister
- Cedric Hardwicke
- Captain Francis Barclay
- Francis L. Sullivan
- Andrew MacAllister
- Willard Parker
- Shively
- Dennis Hoey
- Burford
- Clarence Muse
- Quashy
- William Pullen
- Robert MacAllister
- Walter Reed
- Evans
- Ramsay Hill
- Townsend
- John Hart
- Stuart
- Zora Donahoo
- Elizabeth
- Woody Strode
- Esau
- Ezeret Anderson
- Cudjo
- Kermit Pruitt
- Quarino
- Dan Ferniel
- Caesar
- Rosalind Hayes
- Sally
- Sujata Rubener
- Dancer
- Asoka Rubener
- Dancer
- Don Blackman
- Native
- Willie Bloom
- Pirate
- Bill Coontz
- Pirate
- Paul Cristo
- Auction Guest
- Oliver Cross
- Auction Guest
- Roy Damron
- Pirate
- Karl 'Killer' Davis
- Pirate
- Leonard P. Geer
- Pirate
- Duke Green
- Auction Guest
- Richard Hale
- Ship's Doctor
- Maurice Marks
- Pirate
- George Nardelli
- Auction Guest
- Jimmy Payne
- Minor Role
- Diana Sands
- Native Woman
- Robert Stevenson
- Officer on Captain Barclay's Ship
- Martin Strader
- Auction Guest