- Dan Berg
- Moe
- Dennis Hindman
- Roman Sionis
- Michael Gideon Sherry
- The Kid
- Samuel Wilson
- Larry
- Vincent Prisco
- The Joker
- Brian Backer
- The Detective
- William Sherry
- Killer Croc
- Gabrielle Molica
- Audience Member
- Alexis Taylor
- Audience Member
- Vince Cortese
- Batman
- Elliot Simmons
- Pagliacci Clown Thug
- Jennifer Lelek
- Audience Member
- Joseph Allegretti
- Doctor
- Austin Kinser
- Cyrus Gold
- Robert Didier
- McFearson
- Tyler Kinser
- Main Scarecrow thug
- Brian Arvanites
- Clown Thug
- Ryan Drendel
- Audience Member
- Ben Thogers
- Audience Member
- Tim Mckeewn
- Audience Member
- Zach Rodgers
- Audience Member
- Jenny Russell
- Audience Member
- Edward Perry
- Audience Member
- Isabella Mahoney
- Audience Member
- Alexis Bailey
- Audience Member
- Byron Hicks
- Big Boy
- Lily Ebel
- Audience Member
- Lindsey Spencer
- Audience Member
- Tim Galvin
- Scientist
- Mollie Peery
- Audience Member
- Caleb Peery
- Audience Member
- Brandon Raasch
- Harvey Two Face
- Steve Michalak
- Bullock
- Matt Decker
- Audience Member
- Travis Volmer
- Clown Thug
- Stetson Cross
- Dr. Hugo Strange
- Rhiann Owen
- Gilda
- Patrick Feltz
- Audience Member
- Kyrajo Petie
- Audience Member
