- Billy Bob Thornton
- Morris Buttermaker
- Greg Kinnear
- Roy Bullock
- Marcia Gay Harden
- Liz Whitewood
- Sammi Kane Kraft
- Amanda Whurlitzer
- Ridge Canipe
- Toby Whitewood
- Brandon Craggs
- Mike Engelberg
- Jeffrey Davies
- Kelly Leak
- Timmy Deters
- Tanner Boyle
- Carlos Estrada
- Miguel Agilar
- Emmanuel Estrada
- Jose Agilar
- Troy Gentile
- Matthew Hooper
- Kenneth 'K.C.' Harris
- Ahmad Abdul Rahim
- Aman Johal
- Prem Lahiri
- Tyler Patrick Jones
- Timmy Lupus
- Jeffrey Tedmori
- Garo Daragabrigadien
- Carter Jenkins
- Joey Bullock
- Seth Adkins
- Jimmy
- Chase Winton
- Ms. Cleveland
- Arabella Holzbog
- Shari Bullock
- Nectar Rose
- Paradise
- Lisa Arturo
- Peaches
- Lizz Carter
- Chandalier
- Monique Cooper
- Lolita
- Candace Kita
- China
- Kate Luyben
- Daisy
- Shamron Moore
- Cherry Pie
- Jeffrey Hutchinson
- Baseball Official
- Sonya Eddy
- Saleslady
- Karen-Eileen Gordon
- Saleslady
- Maura Vincent
- Shopper
- Jennifer Carta
- Softball Player Suzy
- Dennis LaValle
- Deaver Dad
- Robert Peters
- Yankee Dad
- Kevin R. Kelly
- Yankee Dad
- Shannon O'Hurley
- All American Mom
- Hunter Cole
- All American Boy
- Wil Myer
- All American Boy
- Pancho Moler
- Kevin
- Jack Acampora
- Yankee Player
- Bretton Blayde
- Yankee Player
- Ryan Cruz
- Yankee Player
- Nick Lovullo
- Yankee Player
- Richard Martinez
- Yankee Player
- Payton Milone
- Yankee Player
- Ernesto Junior Prado
- Yankee Player
- Kirby James Shaw
- Yankee Player
- Cody Ray Thompson
- Yankee Player
- Hayden Tsutsui
- Yankee Player
- Matthew Walker
- Yankee Player
- Darin Rossi
- Umpire
- Gary Rodriguez
- Umpire
- Scott Adsit
- Umpire
- Kevin Makely
- Umpire
- Bobby Scalercio
- Umpire
- Ken Medlock
- Umpire
- Josh Goldfield
- Umpire
- Mike Paciorek
- Umpire
- Jeff Conrad
- State Band Member
- Sam Farrar
- State Band Member
- Alex Greenwald
- State Band Member
- Darren Robinson
- State Band Member
- Tierra Abbott
- Additional Voices
- Kirstin Benson
- Concert Goer
- Jordan Bruhn
- Giants Baseball Player
- Tyler Bruhn
- Giants Baseball Player
- John Carey
- Parent
- Sean Carville
- Hooters Patron
- William Crothers
- White Sox Player
- Wayne Charles Fugate
- Rock Fan
- Parker Goris
- (uncredited)
- Jordan Lindsay Hamm
- Kelly's Friend
- Franky Kane Kraft
- Concert Goer
- Brooke Mackenzie
- Skateboarder
- Brian A Martinez
- Baseball Player
- Tom Miller
- Athletic's Coach
- Darlena Roberts
- Softball Player
- Shane Ryan-Reid
- Concert Goer
- Jennifer Shumaker
- Horrified Mom
- John Francis Sullivan
- Bar Patron
- Alec Vigil
- White Sox Baseball Player
