- Hugh Jackman
- Frank Tassone
- Ray Romano
- Big Bob Spicer
- Welker White
- Mary Ann
- Allison Janney
- Pam Gluckin
- Annaleigh Ashford
- Jenny Aquila
- Stephanie Kurtzuba
- Carol Schweitzer
- Calvin Coakley
- Chad Schweitzer
- Geraldine Viswanathan
- Rachel Bhargava
- Sung Yun Cho
- Joyce - First Agent
- Justin Swain
- Shawn - Second Agent
- Laura Patinkin
- Irene - Third Agent
- Kathrine Narducci
- Sharon Katz
- Brent Langdon
- Todhunter - First Teacher
- Tia DeShazor
- Maya - Second Teacher
- Victor Verhaeghe
- Doug Bressler
- John Scurti
- Joseph Scalvo
- Brian Sgambati
- Conference Speaker
- Rafael Casal
- Kyle Contreras
- Hari Dhillon
- David Bhargava
- Alex Wolff
- Nick Fleishman
- Peter Appel
- Eddie - Custodian
- Darlene Violette
- Fran - First Friend
- Natasha Goss
- Kathy
- Ray Abruzzo
- Howard Gluckin
- Jimmy Tatro
- Jim Boy McCarden
- Kayli Carter
- Amber McCarden
- Jorge Chapa
- Ace Hardware Clerk
- Jane Brockman
- Lorraine Spicer
- Larry Romano
- Cousin Larry
- Madeleine Grace Pace
- Heather - Student
- Catherine Curtin
- Judy Shapiro
- Robert 'Toshi' Kar Yuen Chan
- Stan - Third Boardie
- Finnerty Steeves
- Beth - Fourth Boardie
- Dina Pearlman
- Wendy - Fifth Boardie
- Michael Jay Henry
- Joel - Sixth Boardie
- Jeremy Shamos
- Phil Metzger
- Steve Routman
- Teacher - Rachel's Class
- Rene Ojeda
- Doorman - Frank's Building
- Stephen Spinella
- Thomas 'Tom' Tuggiero
- Miriam Silverman
- Lisa - Fifth Parent
- Gino Cafarelli
- Greg - Eighth Parent
- Pat Healy
- District Attorney
- Will Meyers
- Editor Scott
- Jane Ackermann
- Editor Steph
- Adriana Callori
- Big Bob's Daughter
- Jayden Abrams
- School Kid
- Giuseppe Ardizzone
- School Bus Driver
- Alicia Aswat
- Parent
- John V. Barbieri
- Teacher
- Gregory Barker
- Taxpayer
- Anthony Belfiore
- Taxpayer
- Robert Bellacicco
- Parent
- Luke Brewer
- Student
- Kristoffe Brodeur
- Cellmate
- Michele Cannon
- Book Club Mom
- Kadrolsha Ona Carole
- Park Avenue Patron
- Aidan Christman
- Student
- Richard R. Corapi
- Teacher
- Halle Curley
- High School Student
- Scottie DiGiacomo
- Mother and School Board Member
- Gioianna DiGiorgio
- High School Student
- John DiGiorgio
- Parent / Taxpayer (uncredited)
- Johnny DiGiorgio
- High School Student
- Manny Dunn
- High School Student
- Frank Fernandez
- Taxpayer
- Robin Flanagan
- Lara Lerner
- Angelo Foukas
- Taxpayer
- Jake Friedman
- Male Cheerleader
- Mark D. Gersten
- Taxpayer
- Philip Greene
- Teacher / Bar Patron (uncredited)
- Chandler Hill
- Mayor
- Samantha Kelly
- High School Clarinet Player
- Hannah Kelsy
- High School Trumpet Player
- Joseph Koval
- Parent / Taxpayer (uncredited)
- Mark Lehneman
- Taxpayer / Parent (uncredited)
- Bob Leszczak
- Parent / Taxpayer (uncredited)
- Skylar Lipkin
- Student
- Nancy Lombardo
- Secretary
- Vlad Lopatin
- High School Student
- Victoria Mahal-Sky
- Parent / Taxpayer (uncredited)
- Lucy Marinelli
- High School Student
- Doris McCarthy
- Park Avenue Patron
- Kevin D. McGee
- Building Inspector
- Edward Olaie
- Student
- Frank Osso
- Parent
- Zachary Shea Podair
- Student
- Jivan Xander Ramesh
- School Kid
- Mildred Rios
- Las Vegas Diner Patron
- Rahim Rosen
- Photographer
- Shanaz Sanjana
- Student
- Juliana Scherer
- Teacher's Daughter
- Chris Senn II
- Student
- Austen Shane
- Boy at the Pool
- Isabelle Stanton
- High Schooler
- Amiya Steed
- Student
- Josh Sullivan
- Parent
- Daymien Valentino
- Inmate
- Lauren Yaffe
- Parent / Taxpayer (uncredited)
