- Owen Wilson
- Steve Dallas
- Laura Ramsey
- Angela / Ben's stepmother
- Melissa Rauch
- Marie
- Melanie Ratcliff
- Attractive Neighbor
- Zach Galifianakis
- Ben Baker
- Jay Gates
- Ramada Waiter
- Naomi Lavette
- Erin
- Lauren Lapkus
- Delia Shepard
- Alana De La Garza
- Victoria Riolobos
- Greg Cromer
- Kyle Robertson
- Paul Schulze
- Dave Harken
- Matthew Cornwell
- Stu
- Bridget Gethins
- Patty
- Michael Genevie
- Minister
- Amy Poehler
- Terry Coulter
- Joel Gretsch
- Red Coulter
- Jason Davis
- George
- David Selby
- Karl Stevens
- Ted Huckabee
- Husband
- Karenlie Riddering
- Marta
- Antonio Contreras
- Balthazar
- Dov Tiefenbach
- Zed Starkovitch
- Brett Gentile
- Justin
- Helen LeRoy
- Molly
- Stephanie Northrup
- Bonnie
- Michael Uppendahl
- Officer Norbey
- Tom Key
- Felty Yoder
- Edward Herrmann
- Dr. Vincent
- Antonino Paone
- Mr. Solakian
- Peter Bogdanovich
- Judge Harlan Plath
- Dave Hager
- Baggerz Bartender
- Phillip DeVona
- Pool Player
- Arlo Weiner
- Solomon
- Jenna Fischer
- Alli
- Ellis Weiner
- Connor
- Elving Almeida
- Suburbanite
- Matt Amick
- Suburbanite
- Toochukwu T.C. Anyachonkeya
- Waiter
- Rob C. Baldwin
- Pallbearer
- Bill Bennett
- Golfer
- Ashley Bratcher
- Suburbanite
- Giovanna Braund
- News Station Wardrobe Stylist
- Tavia Brightwell
- Suburbanite
- Samy Burch
- Amish Girl
- Kerry Cashion
- Car Driver
- Carlene Cearley
- Hotel Staff
- Jay N. Cohen
- Veteran Newsman
- Bonnie Cole
- Town Schoolteacher / Farmer's Wife (uncredited)
- Grant Christian Couch
- Teen Boy
- Christopher Cozort
- Bar Patron
- Robert Crayton
- Diner Patron
- Steven 'Trainset' Curtis
- Amish Man
- Christy Daniel
- Street Walker / Driver (uncredited)
- Todd Davis
- Bar Patron
- Noelle DeAtley
- Mourner
- Steve Earnest
- Bar Patron
- Jonathan M. Ewart
- Stage Hand
- Jordan Googe
- Patient Father
- Jan Hartsell
- Sarah - Amish Wife
- Lew Herman
- Mourner
- Cerina E. Johnson
- Bar Customer
- Julionne Johnson
- Bar patron
- Shannon Jones
- Pool Player
- Starr Jones
- TV Station Makeup Artist
- Jerry Keys
- Backhoe Driver
- Tanner Lagasca
- Convenince Store Clerk
- Cassidy Layden
- Girl at Gas Station
- Dennis Layden
- Man at Gas Station
- Grace Layden
- Suburbanite
- Michael Layden
- Boy at Gas Station
- Vitaly Andrew LeBeau
- Amish Child
- George McPherson
- Delivery Guy
- Alex Mechanik
- Amish Boy
- Andy Mottesheard
- Restaurant Patron
- Corey Newton
- Brennen Reynolds / Field Producer (uncredited)
- Brandon Oakley
- Bar Patron
- Ozzy Ojito
- Pedestrian
- Susan Opt
- Mourner
- Emily Pierce
- Bar Patron
- David Dickson Reynolds
- Funeral Goer
- Karen Wheeling Reynolds
- Funeral Guest
- Sarah
- Activist
- Danny Sewell II
- Cop #1
- Paul Shaplin
- Airport Bar Patron
- Blake Smith
- Activist
- Tommy Allen Taylor
- Mr. Shrock
- Thomas Nash Tetterton
- Teenager on Bike
- Kevin Thies
- Kid
- Nick Thies
- Kid
- Suparna Thies
- Chinese Golfer
- Gabriel Tufano Jr.
- Suburbanite
- Diane Tufano
- Suburbanite
- Nick Vernon
- Bar Patron
- Kathy Walton
- Town Folk
- Millie Wannamaker
- Bar Patron
- Lara Watson
- Townsperson
- Matt Whitnack
- Restaurant Patron
- Daniel Williard
- Mourner
- Ebony Wilson
- Flight Attendant
- Neil Wolfman
- Pallbearer
- Janice Mitchell Wyatt
- Funeral Choir Director
- Michael Yurchak
- Dale Pollack
- Rolando Zevallos
- Airport Bar Patron
- Charles Zhao
- Chinese Golfer
