- Jerry Springer
- Master Of Ceremonies
- Kevin McClatchy
- John Noble
- Doug Kusak
- Marty Machody
- Kirk Brown
- Chris Carl
- Mary Faktor
- Cindi Lipton
- Christina Grozik
- Krysta the Producer
- James William Hunter
- Sloan Murphy
- Gary Jochum
- Audio Guy
- Carli Taylor Miluk
- Barista
- Don Mitri
- Tony Vincelli
- Kaleb Singleton
- Robert Silk
- Leslie Thompson
- Miss Centerville
- Crystal Wilson
- Lashae Jackson
- Jonathan Yurco
- Calvin Connors
- Justin Zabor
- Cameraman
- Rob Albach
- Townie #5
- Jack Baun
- Homeowner
- Jocelyn Biddle
- Teenage Girl #4
- John Brandt
- Thug #1
- Jane Darrow
- Groupie #1
- Jennifer Enskat
- Lashae's Assistant
- Molly Hagan
- College Girl #1
- Connor Hollis
- Teenage Girl #2
- Gregg Johnson
- Townie #6
- Maureen Estelle Johnson
- Campaign Representative
- Victor Kuehn
- Customer #3
- Diane Kulak
- Customer #2
- Patrick Lafferty
- Cindi's Assistant
- Tiffany Laufer
- Townie #1
- Danny Lentz
- Sheriff
- Van Jackson
- Proprietor
- Mark Mazzocco
- Voter #1
- Joe McCrystal
- Townie #4
- Daniel Mears
- Marty's Assistant
- Joseph O'Brien
- Employee #1
- Robin O'Rourke
- Customer #4
- Jayme Palker
- Townie #7
- Richard Phillis
- Hired Hand
- Bethany Pugh
- Reporter #4
- James Renner
- Reporter #3
- Patrick Rigney
- Event PA
- Danny Rios
- Thug #2
- Diane Scott
- Make-up Artist
- Krista Ream
- Reporter #2
- Paul Shaia
- Reporter #1
- Thomas Shaia
- Mayor
- Whitney Begue
- Teenage Girl #3
- Logan Fry
- Townie (as Marty Machody Supporter)
- Michael DeAloia
- Pageant Attendee
- William C. Laufer
- Hand Shaker
- Barry Mottier
- Police Officer
- Donna Williams
- Italian Girl
- Rachel Winfield
- Pageant attendee
