- Seth Rogen
- Herschel Greenbaum / Ben Greenbaum
- Sarah Snook
- Sarah Greenbaum
- Molly Evensen
- Clara
- Eliot Glazer
- Christian
- Kalen Allen
- Kevin
- Kevin O'Rourke
- Dane Brunt
- Sean Whalen
- Scientist
- Geoffrey Cantor
- David Greenbaum
- Carol Leifer
- Susan Greenbaum
- Jorma Taccone
- Liam
- Marsha Stephanie Blake
- Inspector Sanders
- Alyse Zwick
- News Anchor
- Dalon Huntington
- Border Patrol Agent
- J Michael Grey
- Border Patrol Agent
- Efka Kvaraciejus
- Fish Monger
- Darryl Bailey Smith II
- Teenage Drone Operator
- Dino Rende
- Teenage Kid
- Peter Kybart
- Old Man
- Joanna Adler
- Professor Kim Ecklund
- Herb Mendelsohn
- Rabbi
- Norm Golden
- Wedding Rabbi
- Al Nazemian
- Cab Driver
- Adam Dunhoff
- Congregant
- Mark Diamond
- Congregant
- Leib Cohen
- Congregant
- Liz Cackowski
- Susan O'Malley
- Tim Robinson
- Prosecuting Attorney
- Betsy Sodaro
- Defense Attorney
- Quinta Brunson
- Female Interviewee
- Kurt Braunohler
- Male Interviewee
- Michael Weaver
- Judge
- David Flick
- Construction Worker
- Raymond Neil Hernandez
- Officer Kadushin
- John Walpole
- Seltzer Man
- Ian Poake
- Devon
- Charles Rogers
- Ellis Island Officer
- Jess Stark
- Female Cashier
- Jon Donahue
- Local Reporter
- Amy Marsalis
- Reporter
- Paul Monte Jr.
- Second Reporter
- Julie Mun
- Third Reporter
- Allan Snyder
- Moderator
- Fabio Polanco
- Audience Member
- Havilah Brewster
- Second Audience Member
- Francis Capone
- Manager
- Alex McAtee
- Bartender
- Dionysius Akeem
- Cliff
- John Varescak
- Self
- Andy S. Allen
- Follower #2
- Tony Amen
- Airline Passenger
- Mike Ancas
- Cab Driver
- Kathryn Andrea
- New York Pedestrian
- Nick Arapoglou
- Todd
- Brad Archie
- Towns person
- Emily Austin
- Yoga Girl
- Brian Babik
- Brooklyn Hipster
- Jimmy Barber Sr.
- Border Crosser
- David Barckhoff
- Pickle Factory Worker
- Lailanie Bautista
- Pedestrian
- Meredith Behm
- Bar Patron
- Greg Black
- Angry Protester
- Gregory Bromfield
- Pedestrian / Debate Attendee (uncredited)
- Paul Castro Jr.
- Freegan
- Alexandre Chen
- Chinese Worker
- Kristin Cochell
- Nika
- Lou Consolo
- Man walking in park
- Vini Costanzo
- Chess Player
- Matt Croyle
- Factory Worker
- Alyssa Curry-Broderick
- Waitress
- William DeAtley
- Jacob Greenbaum
- David Lee Denny Jr.
- Bureaucrat
- Zack Drahusz
- Pedestrian
- Dave Edmonds
- Pedestrian
- Amy Lyn Elliott
- Debate Mic Lady
- Brent Feitl
- Protestor
- Nayib Felix
- (uncredited)
- Jerry Ferrell
- Stock boy at Whole Greens
- Chuck Filipov
- Schlupsk Man
- Vasiliy Finley
- Pedestrian
- Wes Fisher
- Brine Factory Worker
- Aaron D. Frankel
- Pickle Customer
- Taron Germany
- Member
- Jim Hails
- Villager
- Taryn L. Hart
- Villager
- Liz Higgins
- Pedestrian
- Charles Hinshaw
- Follower #1
- Tony Ho
- Feng
- Christopher Holmes
- Man Bun
- John W. Iwanonkiw
- Polish Bar Patron
- Daisy Jade
- ESL Certification Student
- Devante Jones
- Pickle Stand Customer
- Taylor Allen Jones
- Pedestrian / Debate Attendee (uncredited)
- William Kania
- New York City Hot Dog Vendor
- Jessica Kayrouz
- Street Walker
- Cassandra Keegan
- Drunk Wife
- Trudi Kennedy
- Schlupsk Villager
- Rich Kenzie
- Customs Officer
- Pete Landis
- Herschel Supporter
- Jos Laniado
- (uncredited)
- C.J. Lee
- Pickle Stand Customer
- Madelyn Lemmon
- Ellis Island Child
- Michael Lineman
- College Graduate
- Scott Lockhart
- Scientist
- Scott Matheny
- Cab Driver
- David Mattey
- Ivan
- Patricia McBride
- ESL Instructor
- Hubert McCarthy
- Political Debate Attendee / Civilian / Political Riot / Mob Member (uncredited)
- Tiffany Sander McKenzie
- Pedestrian
- F. Robert McMurray
- Ellis Island Immigrant
- Micaela Minner
- Patron at Pickle Stand
- Jake Moon
- Man on Scooter
- Joe Morales
- Protester
- David Morse
- Ellis Island Italian Immigrant
- Brian Nahas
- Peasant
- Christopher Nardizzi
- Office Worker
- Phil Nardozzi
- Shlupsk Farmer
- Jeffrey Neil
- Grandfather
- Rishik Patel
- Lyft Driver #1
- Mandy Patinkin
- Avigdor
- Amber Phares
- Debate Attendee
- Jeff Daniel Phillips
- Actor
- Dwayne Pintoff
- Hershel Follower
- Stephen C. Poland
- Cossack
- Lauren Price
- Brooklyn Resident
- Jessica Proia
- Shlupsk Bar Patron
- Nadia Raphael-Abdelaal
- Priya
- Jordan Rhone
- Billy
- Vince Ruggieri
- Schlucks Villager
- Erin Scerbak
- Mitra
- Eric Sharpe
- Airplane Passenger
- Remington Sinclair
- Passerby
- Ray Sobieralski
- Paramedic
- Dillon Stark
- Background Actor
- Brian E. Stead
- Factory Worker
- Barbra Streisand
- Yentl
- Estes Tarver
- ICE Agent
- Bryan Vavro
- Reporter
- Blase Ward
- Hipster Pickle Stand Customer
- Tiana Ware
- Print Reporter
- Noah J. Welter
- Debate Attendee
- Frank Wilson
- Hershel Follower
- Paul Worley
- Pedestrian
- Nathaniel Yost
- Foreman's Son
- Lydia Zagorski
- Intern
