- Kelly Greyson
- Barbara Leininger / Susquehanna
- Natalie Racoosin
- Young Barbara Leininger / Susquehanna
- Clay Walker
- Fritz Hecklinger
- Jenn Gotzon
- Lydia Barrett
- Ozzie Torres
- Galasko
- Tony Wade
- Hannawoa
- Robert Pierce
- Papa Leininger
- Joanie Stewart
- Mama Leininger
- Joseph Gray
- John Leininger
- James Hartner
- Christian Leininger
- Cassie Brennan
- Young Regina Leininger / Tskinnak
- Kelly Devens
- Young Marie Le Roy
- Victoria Emmons
- Marie Le Roy
- Brett Harris
- Owen Gibson / Souchy or Second Son
- John Telfer
- David Breckenreach / Kalasquay
- Joshua Hunter Magers
- Young David Breckenreach
- Justin Tully
- Young Fritz Hecklinger
- Ian Nelson
- Young Owen Gibson
- Hayley Lovitt
- Regina Leininger / Tskinnak
- Paul Ganus
- Captain Armstrong
- Jesse Medeles
- Mean Native
- Jerry McDonald
- Tall Native
- Jim McKeny
- General Braddock
- Tom Lagleder
- Captain Thomas
- John A. Lorenz
- Medicine Man
- Ron Pinson Jr.
- Chief Selinquaw
- Rich Swingle
- Speculator
- Thurman Bryan
- Sergeant Mueller
- Josh Murray
- George Washington
- Joel King
- Governor Morris
- Barry K. Bedwell
- Benjamin Franklin
- Douglas W. Phillips
- Colonel Mercer
- Ann Lawrence
- Old Widow
- Rene Garcia
- Friendly Warrior
- Arch Bonnema
- Sheriff
- Jubilee Phillips
- Young Hylea
- Lourdes Torres
- Hylea
- Carmen Torres
- Kind Native Woman
- Beall Phillips
- Eunice Fitzgerald
- Rusty Whitener
- Rough Frontiersman
- Ted Johnson
- Mr. Smith
- Bonnie Johnson
- Mrs. Smith
- CJ Legare
- Michaela O'Reilly
- Evangeline Phillips Faith
- Susan Brown
- Honor Phillips
- Sam Brown
- Max Van Bel
- French Officer
- Carl LeMon
- Pastor Muhlenburg
- Sylvia Hutson
- Matron
- Candy Dennis
- Pioneer Woman
- Greg Congleton
- Pioneer Husband
- Ken McNeill
- First Quaker
- Liberty Phillips
- Rebecca Smith
- Ames Arnold
- Second Quaker
- Bill Boyle
- Lieutenant
- John Neely
- John Harrington
- Justice Phillips
- Leftenant Jones
- Brett Moye
- Aide
- James Richards
- Surgeon
- Jake Jensen
- French Cashier
- Josh Phillips
- Tall White Brave
- Rebekah Cook
- Katarina
- Coby Batty
- Scottish Man
- Andrew Torres
- Running Brave
- Providence Phillips
- William Elliott
- Virginia Hope Phillips
- Louise Elliott
- Ellie English
- Civilian
- Insyde
- Native Teen
- Stacey Bradshaw
- Background Extra
- Gabriel Everson
- Piper
- David Foster
- French Scout
- James Harshbarger
- French Trapper
- Alexandra Hernly
- Towns Person
- Gene Jarvis
- Rough Frontiersman
- Sean Kling
- Towns Person
- Ian Kyle
- British Guard
- Rachael Lang
- Rebecca Barrett
- Marshall Dancing Elk Lucas
- Indian Chief
- Ed Mantell
- British Soldier
- William J. Mode
- Parent / Militiaman (uncredited)
- Martin Mongiello
- The Wagon Master
- Sheilah Munger
- Cheesemonger / Indian Squaw (uncredited)
- Gavin Peretti
- Doctor's Assistant
- Randall Perry
- French Soldier
- Blair Peyton
- Townsperson
- Melondy Phillips
- Mob
- Jerry Ramsey
- Indian Chief
- Johnathan Schutz
- French Soldier
- Tim L. Smith
- Dock Worker
- Daniel Stibral
- French Militia Man
- Hillary Styer
- Civilian Women
- Spencer Weaver
- French Soldier
