- Elliott Gould
- Sam Finkelstein
- David DeLuise
- Max Finkelstein
- Elijah Nelson
- Ira J. Finkelstein
- Justin Thomas Howell
- Mikey Amato
- Cynthia Geary
- Libby Wilson
- Angela DiMarco
- Rosie Finkelstein
- Shaye Hodgins
- Clare Wilson
- Julianne Christie
- Jennifer Cameo
- Jenna Levin
- Jessica Wilson
- Meg Savlov
- Ruth Finkelstein
- Tony Doupe
- Walt Wilson
- Jack Fleischmann
- Kyle Wilson
- Lance Rosen
- Sol
- Ashton Herrild
- Jack The Jerk
- Tracy Hyland
- Julie Amato
- Angie Louise
- Mrs. Claus / Edna
- Stephen Hando
- Elf / Louie
- Emily Rudolph
- Mrs. Cratchitt
- Josh Rudolph
- Bob Cratchitt
- Bryan Sevener
- Toadie #1
- Ethan Holle
- Toady #2
- Hillary Dominguez
- Kid Mrs. Claus
- David Frederick White
- Parade Announcer
- Sophia Mitri Schloss
- Karate Don Fan
- Aaron Liao
- Bass Player
- Brandon Murray
- TV Interviewer
- Rosalind Bell
- Cherise's friend
- Carolyn Cox
- Naomi
- Marcel Davis
- Male Airline Escort
- Khanh Doan
- Female Airline Escort
- Isa'Bella' Dupar
- Extra
- Allen Galli
- Santa Leftkowitz
- Laura Kenny
- Mrs. Levy
- Hank Manriquez
- Busker Tipper
- Lino Marioni
- Joseph
- Vanessa N. Nelson
- Party guest
- Rachel Pate
- Stewardess
- Connor Rice
- Spike
- Martha Romero-Flora
- Florida Airline Escort
- Paul W. Shapiro
- Bernie
- Andy Stein
- Sarah
- Kristina Thalén
- Red Carpet Reporter
- Marshall Verdoes
- Drummer
- Cameron Washington
- Sugar Plum Fairy
- Mira Wellington
- Nutcracker
- Amber Wolfe Wollam
- Cherise
- Hans Altwies
- Jack the Jerk's Dad
- Wendy Bones
- Party Goer
- Kieth Conner
- Film set crew
- Shaundi Li Draven
- Parade Watcher
- Audrey Ella Gainey
- Play Audience Member
- Rene Hamlet
- Reporter
- Chris Hazenberg
- Man in Parade
- Rachelle Henry
- Play Audience Member
- Ashley Morrison
- Waitress
