- Emmanuelle Vaugier
- Ally Leeds
- Dean Cain
- Danny Donner
- Richard Ruccolo
- Justin Larose
- Cynthia Gibb
- Samantha Ryland
- Sierra McCormick
- Jackie Ryland
- Jared Gilmore
- Jonas Ryland
- Sarah Thompson
- Tina
- Clyde Kusatsu
- Mr. Halligan
- John Burke
- Carl Ryland
- Caia Coley
- Carol
- Marla Maples
- Brandy
- Keith Dobbins
- Santa Claus
- Barry Barnholtz
- Dan
- Shirell Ferguson-Coleman
- First Waitress
- Katie Condidorio
- Second Waitress
- Matt Gaydos
- Jeff
- Denver Dowridge
- Peter
- Shanie Evans
- Christmas Party Singer
- Brock Burnett
- Tree Lot Owner
- Yaron Kaplan
- Hannukah-Bush Shopper
- Stewart F. Lane
- Mike Edelstein
- Bonnie Comley
- Janet Edelstein
- Renee A. Gilmore
- Santa's Helper
- Jay Smith
- Co-Worker #1
- Mike Korich
- Co-Worker #2
- Anna Barnholtz
- Kate Edelstein
- Aidan Schenck
- Michael Edelstein
- Michael Healey
- News Reporter on Radio
- Michael Ciminera
- Ryland Employee
- Richard Gnolfo
- Ryland Employee
- David Dustin Kenyon
- Family member
