- Danny Aiello
- Frank Pesce, Sr.
- Anthony LaPaglia
- Frank Pesce, Jr.
- Lainie Kazan
- Mrs. Pesce
- Frank Pesce
- Vito Pesce
- Robert Forster
- Sgt. Tartaglia
- Ron Karabatsos
- Philly the Nap
- Rick Aiello
- Jimmy Vitello
- Vic Manni
- Louie Tucci
- Paul Lazar
- Needle Nose Nipton
- Pete Antico
- Tony
- Donna Magnani
- Madeline Pesce
- Darren Bates
- Sal Las Benas
- Tony Sirico
- Chink Fortunado
- Richard K. Olsen
- Father Lowery
- Richard Cerenzio
- Dom the Bomb
- Philip Ciccone
- Rocky Sav
- Joe Gironda
- Carmine Tucci
- Vic Noto
- Auggie Falcone
- Sal Ruffino
- Angelo
- Sam Shamshak
- Irv the pawnbroker
- Adam LaVorgna
- Frankie (age 8)
- Frank Acciarito
- Jimmy (age 8)
- Don Blakely
- Sgt. Jones
- Hope Alexander-Willis
- Lucy Sills
- Leonard Termo
- Dr. Puccini
- Lou Criscuolo
- Ticket buyer
- Karen Duffy
- Maria Rios
- Julie Lott
- Julie (usherette)
- David Ferraro
- Cousin Leo
- Teddy Cleanthes
- Pit boss
- Vincent Chase
- Army eye doctor
- Shirley Swanger
- Nun
- Tom Ellis
- Newscaster
- Tony Lip
- Nicky Bad Lungs
- Vinnie Curto
- Zippers Bad Lungs
- Mario Todisco
- Zippers' Bodyguard
- Richard Tacchino
- Social Club Waiter
- Rocco Savastano
- Social Club Bartender
- Jerry Guarino
- Chickens
- Bill Ricci
- Mickey the Dwarf
- Nicky 'Pops' Anest
- Tommy the Geep
- George 'Aggie' Anest
- Joe Numbers
- Vito 'Baldie' Boccanfuso
- Johnny Cake
- Anne Sterling
- Maternity Nurse
- Bill Phillips
- Lottery Finalist
- Joe Roberto
- Patrolman Tollen
- Jim Ondatje
- Patrolman #2
- Anthony Montes
- Jesus Rios
- Jessen Noviello
- Needle Nose (age 8)
- Charles Haugk
- Tucci's Driver
- Alexander Fehr Blue
- Baby on Train
- Ingrid Van Dorn
- Nurse
- Giovanni Gianoni
- Italian Band Singer
- Lee Boyd
- Italian Wedding Band
- Cecil McKiethen
- Italian Wedding Band
- Jerome Alfano
- Italian Wedding Band
- Eugene Kobisky
- Italian Wedding Band
- Joe Franklin
- Self
- John W. Beach
- Fred Silvers
