When Peter and friends encounter the legendary "Jack Sharp", a large trout that even Peter's father failed to catch, they try to reel the fish in once and for all. But catching a fish is a lot harder than it looks and besides, what do you do with a big, bad trout once you've caught it? When Cotton-tail leaves the burrow in search of her new playmate, the Shrew, Peter must scour the woods and find his sister before a hungry Old Brown does.